This past week, we have been studying the article by Sam Dragga and Dan Voss title “Cruel Pies: The Inhumanity of Technical Illustration” as well as the authors’ response to a reader’s response in our study of logos, ethos, and pathos. The article lends itself to being analyzed with any and all of these modes of persuasion—that of logic, character, and emotion. I will take some time to analyze the article with each of these modes.
First, I will start with the persuasive mode of logos—the logical appeal. In using the concept of deduction (a comparison of general to specific) and using a syllogism, one can see the logical argument Dragga and Voss attempt to make in the “Cruel Pies” article. The basic argument is 1) Graphs and charts are neutral. 2) Neutral is cold-hearted. 3) Graphs and charts are cold-hearted. They are essentially arguing that since charts that record annual deaths of people in certain professions or with certain products do not contain any humanizing qualities about them, then they are unable to fully encompass the tragedy of the loss of human life.
Next, I will look to the persuasive mode of ethos (character) in order to draw conclusions from the “Cruel Pies” article. If we think of this article in terms of situated ethos (something that is preexisting, dealing with Truth and character), then we can see that the authors have done research into technical graphs and charts for companies and organizations. But, this article really lends itself more to invented ethos (a character that is constructed or created and the creation of a persona based on truth) and therefore to Aristotle’s three necessities for ethos development. The first necessity is practical sense. This article fulfills it because it is obvious that the writers have done their research and studies on the subject (there is an extensive works cited list). As we learned in class after reading the article, Dragga is an expert in the field of technical communications, so that also serves the credibility of the article. The next necessity is to establish a good moral character. The authors heavily advocate to humanize graphs and charts depicting fatality numbers in company presentations. In doing this, they establish that their moral intent is to make sure that people do not become numbers in company statistics, but rather to keep them in mind for the company. The third necessity is that of securing good will. Similar to establishing a good moral character, the authors argue that in making the issue of fatality real, companies will be better able to handle how dangerous jobs or products might be and to make them safer.
Finally, I will look to the emotional appeal—pathos—to glean insight from Dragga and Voss’s article. Dragga and Voss, in the “Cruel Pies” article, draw heavily on the rhetorical concept of enargeia, which is vivid depictions of something (these must be visual). In the article, they provide examples of how they propose to humanize charts and graphs by taking the existing chart or graph data and adding a visual representation to it, for example a baby in a walker hovering precariously near stairs with an arrow pointing to an ambulance . Now, just how silly or ridiculous these depictions may be (as pointed out in a reader’s response), they still are still considered enargeia because they have a visual emotional appeal. Dragga and Voss are trying to argue that by putting a picture of a baby in a walker by stairs, they can appeal to the emotions of people in the company so that they might be called to action to rectify the problem.
As one can see, the article “Cruel Pies: The Inhumanity of Technical Illustration” by Sam Dragga and Dan Voss can be interpreted using the three modes of persuasion—logos, ethos, and pathos. Although this article is more effective in some modes than others, it ultimately achieves its goal of displaying the argument that technical graphs and charts need to be more humane so that they do not underplay what the charts and graphs are giving information for—especially when human life is lost. Whether one agrees with the authors or not, they are able to use the three modes of rhetorical persuasion in order to present their argument.
No comments:
Post a Comment