The past couple of days, we have been discussing our opinions on if Aspasia should be taught in rhetoric classes or not. It seems like most of us have decided that Aspasia would be a useful person to study for contributions to the field of rhetoric, and I would have to agree. Much of what was discussed in class on Monday was what I had written down on our free write for the topic. Even though we do not have any primary sources of Aspasia’s work, she is no less important to the field of rhetoric than say, Socrates (who we also do not possess any primary sources for and he was a contemporary of Aspasia). According to the Glenn article, Aspasia was no less influential in her time than Socrates or any of the other rhetoricians that scholars study at this time. As an outsider of Athens (she was from the present day Turkey area) Aspasia was highly educated, and became sought after for her skills as a rhetorician and speech writer. She lived and worked with Pericles—the highly influential ruler of Athens—and she ran a salon out of their home. (If I were teaching this in a class, I would make sure to include all of this information). I think if I were to teach Aspasia in a class, I would group her together when talking about Socrates and the Sophists. I would give a bit of history about Pericles as well (despite his and Aspasia’s connection to each other). If this were for a high school class, I don’t think I would make a huge deal about Aspasia being left out or forgotten for so long—I would mention it, but I don’t think kids would be as interested in debating about her like we did in class. Who knows, though. They could surprise me, so I would think asking about whether we should teach her or include her in studying rhetoric could produce a lot of really great conversation on the topic. I suppose I would have to get a “feel” for how a particular class can handle (or not) such debates. I do think I would note how Aspasia was doing all of these great things as a woman in Athens at this time, and probably ask students to compare and/or contrast her with Sappho. The two are similar in doing great work in the field of rhetoric at a time when women were not really allowed to do such things. This might also elicit a discussion on how these women were able to do what they did in the time that they lived.
Wednesday, April 18, 2012
Saturday, April 7, 2012
Personal Opinions in Rhetoric Class
When discussing matters of personal opinion, I do think those personal opinions count for something in a rhetoric class. Even though arguments should be based on fact, when it comes to the modes of persuasion, these are very much based on a certain logic (logos), a person’s character (ethos), and the emotions of a person (pathos). So long as someone can back up their personal opinion with solidly stated facts or logical conclusions, I don’t see why we shouldn’t include person opinion into class discussion. By this, I mean that if a person is just giving opinion after opinion about a topic and others as audience can’t see the logical or factually pertinent (as we, I am sure, have all experienced in our various classes), then there is no valid reason to give opinion—such a person is only speaking so that they may be heard, not so the discussion can move forward. Personal opinion has the opportunity, if used responsibly, to give further insight into the topic being discussed—personal opinion is able to enrich what is currently being discussed in the class. I think that there is a great opportunity in the use of personal opinions in rhetoric class. I don’t see how a class would be able to operate without personal opinion being interjected into class discussion. Part of rhetoric is to persuade others of your argument, and a way to do that (in thinking of ethos and pathos) is to insert your (well supported) personal opinion. I think it takes great skill to be able to do this, rather than to say “I think this because of reasons.” Instead, someone might say “I think this because in looking to…we can see…” and so on and so forth. I think the best way to see this lies within giving an opinion on an author’s persuasive argument. Just stating whether one agrees with the author or not is a form of personal opinion in and of itself. We, as students of rhetoric, must look to what we see that the author is trying to persuade his or her audience of (contextual evidence), and from that, form the basis of our own opinions. Therefore, we are relying on how the author appeals to our own persuasive modes (logos, ethos, pathos) for us to form an opinion of their argument. This skill, in my own opinion, is a very important one to possess because it allows us to be able to form a more valid opinion of what we are trying to side with in an argument. Basically, if one is able to find support, then one can more successfully support a personal opinion—especially in a rhetoric class.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)