Sunday, January 29, 2012

Examining Cluster Criticism at Work

As we learned in class this week, there are four major types of criticisms in rhetoric—ideological, cluster, generic, and narrative. Without having to go into too much detail about the rest, I’d like to focus on how cluster criticism works within the frames of the Ancient Rhetorics for Contemporary Students (ARCS) textbook and the Wikipedia article on rhetoric, featuring the similarities, differences, and what it means to us, the rhetoric students.
Before I get into any further details about the article, I’d like to take a brief moment to explain what criticism and cluster criticism are in the field of rhetoric. Criticism is simply how we look at an argument in different ways to better understand it. Cluster criticism asks us to look at the words and terms that continually appear in an argument—or in this case, the articles about rhetoric. Both of these concepts will be key in determining the underlying argument and/or theme in both ARCS and in the Wikipedia article.  I’ve chosen cluster criticism because I think it is interesting how a repeated word or phrase can be so influential to the reader (in this case) or listener, and because I was in the group who looked at cluster criticism for our textbook (but, hey, there is more I have to say about it).
In first looking to ARCS, there are several words that tend to come up frequently and repeatedly in the text.  These words (listed below) contain several hints about what the authors are trying to say about rhetoric.
Persuasion, argument, speech/debate, informed, audience, language, exchange, context, deliberate, art, engage, opinion, listening, disagree(ment), practice, ideology, power, and facts
The list of words from the Wikipedia article (below), while producing a few similar terms, is different than that of ARCS.
Discourse, domain, public (especially in reference to discourse and domain), scope, art, engage, political, persuasion, classical, civic, study, and context
As one can see, there are several differences and similarities between the two texts. Don’t worry, I’ll glean some of my insights into what this means in studying cluster criticism.
What do these lists, then, say about the value of rhetoric? Several things.  If we first look to the ARCS list, words like exchange, opinion, practice, ideology, engage, language, and facts (just as a sample of the terms) appear several times throughout the text. What do these terms, then, say about our ARCS textbook? These terms or words say that this text will be dealing more in theory and application of rhetoric rather than just the history of how rhetoric came about in Western culture. The concern is for students studying rhetoric to be able to take these important  concepts and keep them in mind when practicing and applying rhetoric in, not only their classes, but also in everyday life. I would also venture to say that these terms are important when thinking about the different ways in which rhetoric works around us all the time (like in advertising).
The list of terms from the Wikipedia article, however, says different (though not very different, and certainly not very very different) things from ARCS. Words like public, civic, political (in relation to discourse and domain), study, and classical have a very different view on rhetoric than that of ARCS. These terms, while they do suggest some theory, apply more to a historical context than that of application. This article is more about information of what rhetoric is rather than explicitly telling readers how to use rhetoric. Because it is defining what rhetoric is, some theory is discussed in the Wikipedia article, which explains why words like art, engage, and persuasion appear on both lists of words from both texts.
When examining a text, then, cluster criticism can be a valuable tool in determining the point the argument of that text. I suppose my question to readers is what are other ways we can make use of cluster criticism? If you used one of the other criticisms, what was that experience like for you? What conclusions did you reach? (If you are in my class on the discussion board, I look forward to seeing what you have to say. If you are reading my blog, I also look forward to what you have to say in the comments).  

No comments:

Post a Comment